Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Three Strikes and You're Out!
I definitely learned a lot from writing this paper so far. I am happy that Dr. Chambliss told me I was off to a good start because at least that gave me encouragement. I was not really sure what to think of the material I had written but I guess it sounded better than I expected. Well, at least I have a solid thesis! :) I guess I just need to take it one step at a time.
I decided to discuss the topic of baseball in regards to racial segregation and gender inequality. Throughout the course of 50 years, African Americans were striving to find their place in the baseball industry, especially the major leagues. Women were given the chance to explore the baseball diamond as many men went off to war in the 1940s. Baseball owners were worried that the industry would lose popularity and not survive the war. Well, obviously as we see now, baseball maintained a great fan base.
On a side note, I must admit that I love the Encyclopedia of Chicago! It is a great source for secondary sources! YAY!
Monday, March 30, 2009
Paper
Sunday, March 29, 2009
Big Bill v. Dever
William E. Dever had a completely opposite approach in dealing with the 18th Amendment of Prohibition. Instead of aiding the gangsters in Chicago, he cracked down completely. He strictly enforced the law and stated at one of his conferences that not enforcing the law is being a traitor to the United States. What I found most interesting about Dever is that he personally did not agree with Prohibition.
Before I began my research, I thought it was going to be very difficult to find primary sources on these two mayors; however, I soon discovered that the New York Times database is a great website for primary sources. Also, thanks to Daniela’s pervious post, I found great primary and secondary sources on the Chicago Encyclopedia. Lastly, JSTOR and ProQuest provide great secondary sources.
I still have a lot of work to do on my research paper. I need to cite all of my sources, as well as, edit my entire paper. I was able to get a great start on this paper but I need more information and need to add about page to complete it. I appreciate the notes that Professor Chambliss emailed me about my rough draft and should be able to complete my paper with in the next two weeks.
Friday, March 27, 2009
Progress of the Research Paper and Other History-Related Projects
Regarding the actual argument of my paper, I have a thesis (as discussed in last blog). The second part of this thesis has proven to be somewhat more difficult to prove than the first. In the second part I am arguing that World War I breaking out sped up German-American integration into Chicagoan society. It has been really difficult distinguishing to what extent this is process of immigration was stimulated by anti-German sentiment associated with the war (German-Americans feeling the need to denounce their cultural heritage) or the decline in / halt to German immigration due to the war (the argument that German cultural institutions could not preserve their ethnicity and traditions because they relied on a continued influx of German immigrants to do so and that immigration flow was halted by WWI).
In this past week, I have also been to the Fire Department and scanned five primary historical documents. The majority of my documents deal with the Great Mall Fire in Winter Park, but others deal with fire safety in the immediate Winter Park area (such as adequately equipping a nursing home with fire safety measures). As I continue to find out more about these photographs and artifacts in the following week, my next blog will deal with their historical significance.
Monday, March 23, 2009
Metropolis
Politically there is a class struggle between the rich and poor, and class identity becomes really defined. Economically a class struggle is seen once again between the rich and poor as the rich seem to prosper over everything the lower class is doing. The idea of industrialization is also seen as a bad thing as it is portrayed as a very powerful and almost unstoppable entity that will only cause chaos and destruction. Obviously, the process of industrialization isn't something that has completely torn up the United States but it has definitely come with some costs, especially to minority groups as portrayed in the film.
Chapter 22: Imperialism and U.S. Power
President Roosevelt was the main iniator of this process as he felt that in order to become a more prosperous nation we must conquer and control new territories and resources to become a global power. Not only did we establish better relations with other countries at this time but we made trade easier by creating the panama canal which allowed for more efficient transportation of goods from one part of the U.S. to the other.
It was also during this time that WWI broke out in which the U.S. really gained power from as they emerged as the new global leader. No longer was the the world multipolar but rather bipolar as the U.S. and Russia became the new global powers.
Chapter 20: Industrial Society
The idea of eugenics during this time was also seen. Known as "quasi-science," it supported the idea of racial hierarchy. The goal was to increase the fitness of a nation by increasing birth and immigration amongst the fit and decreasing the amount of people who were unfit.
Chapter 19: HIST 143: Summary
As these events took steam so did the railroad industry that allowed for transportation of goods, services, and people to be spread across the nation. Among the top entrepreneurs in this was a man named J.P. Morgan who establishes a huge trust in in the railroad system in addition to steel, which ends up bringing about a mass amount of centralization and power to many.
Another entrepreneur was Rockeffeller who made his living off the oil refining business. He also created new types of innovation like new management styles such as the "horizontal business" that basically monopolized everything in in oil refining. In contrast to this process another growing business person know as Carnegie controlled every part of the steel business through his mangament system know as "vertical integration". It was this system that allowed him to control everything from top to bottom of his business.
With these new innovations came more production and efficiency. Profits were increased and costs were low. All of these things led to America becoming what it is today but socially it would cause a large rift between the rich and poor as new innovations have the ability to create tensions among many people but especially employers and employees.
Jazz and politics
To me this period in American history, from the end of the First World War to the beginning of the second, has some of the most interesting times in the United States. Reasoning for this? To start this was the time when one of America’s greatest musical traditions began to grow and develop; it was in this period of time that Jazz became big. To tell the truth I was disappointed by the lack of information there was on this in either of the two books. For starters, Chicago was Jazz’s second home, where after New Orleans it grew into a national and international popular music style.
Another thing that caught my attention about this era is the importance of the mayors. It seems that the mayors of cities such as Chicago held a lot of power at this time, and were well known by the citizens of the city. I have no idea how much power mayors hold now, but they do not seem to have the same amount of power or publicity as I do not even know who our mayor in Orlando is or what he or she has done. This also includes the increase of the importance of the workers in politics, as politicians began to target them and their needs instead of the upper and middle class.
Of course, another trend in politics began around the Great Depression. When FDR was elected into office, the government became much more involved in the lives of the citizens. This is something I believe can be linked to today, where with Obama in office the government plans on making the United States a more socialized country. The times are similar to the great depression (although not as harsh). Whether or not a more socialized country is good or not is of course a sticky conversation, with America’s distaste for communism, but as the economy goes down, it seems that the government takes a larger role in providing for its people.
This change in politics, along with the growth of one of my favorite music styles gives me great appreciation for this era.
Sunday, March 22, 2009
the great depression
Running Back-and-Forth
We both had five articles in hand and made sure to note the materials we took so no one duplicated the articles we were about to scan. Of course, it had to a fairly windy day so we were worried about our articles flying everyone but we both held a tight grip on them. Then we got back in the car and headed to school but there was no parking! Great! Now we were going to have to walk from the parking garage to the library in the wind...not good! Well, we made it there in no time.
The scanning area was rather crowded but with no one who was scanning anything. There was a couple computers open but one computer would not turn on and the scanner attached to the other computer would not turn on. Plus we both are not Mac experts so the directions were hard to understand when trying to use a Mac. Nicole worked her magic and asked a girl to trade computers with us. She was not very happy but the sign clearly says that we have priority over other people who are not scanning materials.
Once we finally got started everything started to run smoothly. We borrowed Jump Drives from the Library, which was very handy! Just in case anyone forgets their Jump Drive, know that the library will lend you one for 24 hours! Also know that the articles are not in the best condition so sometimes the scans will not look perfect. We both agreed that we gave it our best shot with the materials we had in hand! I think the hardest and most time consuming part is making the trip to the fire house and then scanning the material. Once you get all the scanning done, you can do the summaries on your own time! :)
Saturday, March 21, 2009
Research on the History of Chicago
Therefore the research I conducted within the past week was focused on narrowing the subject down and finding a thesis. One thing that has been catching my eye while reading our textbook and also reading the “City of Big Shoulders” book is that these sources generally point to the fact that German immigrants where more widely accepted by American society than Southern European or Irish immigrants. These ‘textbook-like’ sources also assert that the lack of resentment towards German immigrants had to do with the fact that they adapted more readily to American society than other immigrant groups. While I can certainly agree that up to World War I, German immigrants were received well in Chicago, my research and reading of scholarly articles about the German immigrant community and findings from primary sources do not necessarily support the claim that German immigrant groups assimilated faster to American life than other groups. My paper will disprove this claim, showing that the German immigrants led a social and cultural life almost entirely restricted to the replica of German institutions in Chicago and that they lived secluded from Americans and / or other immigrant groups. I will show that the proclaimed “fast integration” into American culture and life did not actually take place until the onset of World War I, when anti-German sentiment and propaganda prompted German immigrants to renounce their own cultural agenda.
At the beginning, finding resources was a rather tedious process. My initial assumption that the fact that German is my first language and would make research easy for me did not necessarily hold true, because either the German sources I found were not accessible through our library or interlibrary loan, and many German sources were from an earlier time period or off-subjects. The majority of my scholarly articles now are some form of collaboration between German and American university scholars. Even though I had placed my interlibrary loan request before Spring Break, I am still waiting on some sources. In general, I can say that for very basic information and a starting point, the reference section was my best bet – and there are many more useful reference books besides the ones we were shown in the library session.
Regarding primary sources the Internet has proven very useful. Most of my findings come from the digital collection of the Library of Congress, specifically its “American Memory” or domestic history collection (http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/index.html). The collection is organized by topics, which makes searching far easier. The Chicago Historical Society also has what they call “History Files” on the most important subjects in Chicago History. It did not necessarily help with a topic as specific as mine but is a great source for more widely known events. The page also offers a photo gallery, compiled bibliographies and historic files regarding the topics (http://www.chicagohs.org/history/). Another very valuable source is the Encyclopedia of Chicago, which offers information on all kinds of topics as well as links to primary sources (http://www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/).
Friday, March 20, 2009
Post WWI Race Issues
Parking on Campus is Horrible
I selected five different articles from five different time periods. The earliest article I selected was from 1967 about Winter Park adopting higher pay wages for fire fighters. The article states that Orlando patrolman have experienced a higher increase in wages then Winter Park patrolman – “Orlando has set a starting salary of $5,678 for a patrolman with increase over five years to $6,988”. The second article I scanned was about the troubled times Winter Park faced in the mid 1970’s. The article explains the political missteps that city officials have taken during the mid 1970’s. The author of the article continues and states that at some point these city officials even the city commissioners will eventually need to take responsibility for the actions. The Winter Park Fire Station buys new super trucks in 1982 and then two years later one of those new trucks accidentally hits a man while responding to an emergency call. Lastly, a 1998 article, “Anti-terrorism training is next wave for firefighters” highlights all of the different responsibilities that fire departments have.
Overall, the experience of scanning was frustrating due to the scanners not working and the lack of parking on campus. The people at the library did assist us; however, they were not able to fix the majority of the problems that we faced. I wish the process was faster and less frustrating; however, we successfully scanned all of our articles.
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
African Americans in Chicago, Chapter 9
Saturday, March 14, 2009
Digital History, The Winter Park Fire Department, and Student Action



Despite what people might believe, this is a blog about the digital project for HIS 143. The problem is that students work on their own schedule. Without a concentrated effort that forces them to think about the project or events directly linked to the project--no project posts. They are required to post however, so we get some very interesting post on the weekly readings. As always, this a failure of the professor (it always the professor's fault) and I will get my usually negative feedback in student evaluations and deep feeling of shame that come from not realizing the full dream associated with the original ideas behind the project. Digital history is the future, there is great stuff all over the web. Nonetheless, the humble projects associated with my classes are works in progress. The idea is solid. Use students to create an online digital archive based on the City of Winter Park Fire Department's scrapbook. We are working with the Winter Park Public Library and our project will fit nicely with other online content they offer the community. Indeed, our goals are modest and the students can complete the project as designed. It is just a question of timing.
I'm working with them on the project. The Winter Park Sinkhole remains one of the most memorable events linked to the city. It is also something the Fire Department documented closely( it a truth of urban life--if it not a crime--odds are they will send the fire department to do it). The images you see were taken by members of the Fire Department in 1981 when the sinkhole suddenly appeared in Winter Park. The Fire Department monitored the sinkhole. These are great images and as I work with the scanner at our college to make sure they are formatted as great digital images, I get a sense of the problems and triumphs by students face. I'm sure the students will blog about the digital project. I and anyone who reads this blog will be impressed. I'm sure....willing to bet money...not my money, but somebody's money.
Monday, March 9, 2009
Jumping In
Journalism played a huge role in the early part of the 20th century but then again the media still has a way with words these days. It seems that journalists are considered to be authorities are various matters that can sometimes be out of their expertise. For instance, during the early 20th century, there were muckrakers and yellow-journalists. Words are powerful tools and can easily persuade the opinions of people.
Working conditions were far from perfect. It just seems like the U.S. had a hard time getting the workplace to be a friendly environment. Racism and sexism stood in the way of developing working places fore everyone. Young men would serve as soldiers but once they returned to the homeland, it was assumed that their jobs would be handed right back to them. What did they expect everyone else to do? Meanwhile, African Americans did not get the same treatment! They were efforts to keep these men out of the military so IQ tests were used as justification. Without a doubt, that did not last long. It seems hard to imagine experiencing freedom abroad but then your own country limits your opportunities. Why did African American soldiers want to come back to the U.S.? Their lives seemed to be better abroad! What was intriguing about the United States throughout history?
The imperialistic approach the U.S. took during the early part of the 2oth century seemed to help define the United States today. We still find ourselves looking to be involved in the lives and experiences of our global neighbors. The coastlines on the Atlantic and Pacific do not serve as our boundaries of power. U.S. imperialistic thoughts have continued to expand our coastline abroad.
Sunday, March 8, 2009
(catching up on old blogs) WWI
At the beginning of World War I, America, under the leadership of Woodrow Wilson, tried to remain neutral. But this proved very hard, because many Americans were immigrants from western European countries that were in the Triple Entente (Great Britain, France and Russia) against the other countries in the Triple Alliance (Germany, Austria-Hungary, and The Ottoman Empire/Italy). The fact the many Americans shared a lot of cultural similarities with Great Britain, and had a lot of banking investments in with them made it hard for them to stay neutral. However for Wilson’s first full term he kept the United States out of the war, declaring he wanted a “Peace without Victory”. But this did not look to be possible.
After Germany began using submarine warfare as a way of combat, the blew up one of Great Britain’s passenger ships (because they thought it was transporting a large store munitions, which it most likely was) the Lusitania, many American’s were upset because there were American passengers on it. As well, the American’s intercepted the ‘Zimmerman Telegram’, which was from Germany to Mexico, telling them to attack America. The German’s said that if they did, they would help them regain lost provinces. This was disconcerting to America, so we declared war, and became officially on the side of the Triple Entente.
The war effort in America was a ‘Total’ war effort. In past wars, America had not had tough times as they did during the World War, with the fact that they had been mainly fighting small wars against Indians and such. In the total war effort, they rationed food and clothing and other things, with all industries helping out the war effort so that we could most effectively win the war. We created things such as the War Industries Board, the National War Labor Board, and sold liberty bonds to make money.
(catching up on old blogs) Imperialism
The United States began looking abroad into global expansion once the “frontier” was completely conquered. According to Turner, the United States economic and social growth heavily rested on the fact that we were expanding westward. He wondered how The United States was going to continue to prosper now that the frontier was gone. So people began looking globally. Specifically the protestant missionaries who wanted to save the souls of the ‘ignorant Asian’, and the businessman who wanted to have contacts in other countries and build lucrative businesses there. These helped to create the idea in America for ‘Imperialism’.
Because the idea of Imperialsm was becoming so popular, people began thinking about what it would take for this to actually happen. Writer, Alfred Thayer Mahan, realized that the only way to truly become a super power would be to have control of the seas, and this could only be done through a strong navy. This would also mean having swift travel thought the seas, including a canal thought Panama (to travel easily from the Pacific Ocean to the Atlantic).
The United States began gaining provinces and countries as spheres of influences and places to hold naval stations. These included, Cuba, the Philippines, and Hawaii. Roosevelt, during his presidency, wanted to make sure that the world knew how powerful that America had become, and sent the United States navy “The Great White Fleet” on tour around the world. This was in response to the fact that he, Roosevelt, had struck a deal with Japan saying that he would make sure American’s would be nice the Japanese Immigrants here. But he did not want the Japanese to think we were a weak/wempy nation, so he sent the navy on tour around the world. Part of his policy “speak softly and carry a bid stick”.
By World War I, the United States was a world power with a lot of weight in discussions help by the other world powers at that time including Great Britain, France, Italy, etc.
metropolis!
I really enjoyed the movie metropolis. I love watching old movies. It was just as entertaining as the old Buster Keaton movies. The movie was very informative of German’s view of that era. I really liked how the main character was holding onto the clock, trying to make it time to go, but it would never get there. The dancer girl, that all the men were lusting after was strange. That whole scene was kind of weird. I think the movie, with what it was showing about the era and all the workers, and their lives would have done without that odd scene.
I liked the way they showed how the big business factory owner did not care one bit what happened in the explosion of at the factory until he heard that his son was involved. This is a great description of the business owners of that time. They had little care for the safety of their workers, solely wanting to make a large profit. They did not take into account the long hours and low wages, and how it affected the workers lives.
It was interesting that this was a view of the future of that time. It was not accurate obviously, because we have so many laws about how workers can be treated and what wages ought to be, that few people are treated unfairly. And workers compensation allows the workers to have money when injured on the job, to pay for their doctors bills and time to recover. This is differently from how the movie depicted that the workers were still treated poorly, however at the end of the movie they showed that one day the workers and the factor owners would come together in harmony.
All in all I enjoyed the movie, and can’t wait to watch the next one! J
Friday, March 6, 2009
Metropolis
Metropolis was filmed in 1927 but the screenplay is envisioned to take place in 2026 and the film portrays the producers view on how society would look by then. In my opinion, the movie showed a view of the future that was too dark and too pessimistic. Maybe I can only say this with so much certainty because I live close to the projected time period and the dark premises foreseen by Metropolis do not seem to come true anytime soon. However, even if I had lived in 1927, I would probably not retract or alter the statement. While it is true that the 1920s were characterized by somewhat of a class struggle between wage labor and industrialist, increased unionization and increased industrialization, the film fails to take into account the positive societal movements that took place during the era. Certain aspects of the Progressive Era were designed to directly counter the adverse effects of industrialization and promote better living conditions and greater social equality for all. An example could be laws regarding occupational safety standards many progressive legislatures as well as Congress passed during the time period. These measures were able to offset some of the harsh working conditions once can see in the movie. In addition, these movements were largely driven by the middle class and often supported by philanthropist capitalists such as Andrew Carnegie and his gospel of wealth. This contradicts the movie’s assumption of total class struggle at least to some extent.
Overall, watching Metropolis was a more enjoyable experience than expected. While certainly not my choice of movie for a weekend or leisure, the content of the movie actually related very well to the material covered in class.
Freder looks like a girl
Monday, March 2, 2009
Metropolis
When Metropolis began I was confused about the direction of the film in relation to what we were studying in class. I researched the film and found out that the film was made in 1927 but was set in the year 2026. The film depicted what the director and the novelist believed was the direction of America. They based there interpretation of the future on the political, economical and social events of the current time period – the early 19th century. The city Metropolis was physically split between the underground industrial world and the above ground managerial world. The film highlighted the major economic class problems that were promoted in the early 19th century through this physically separation of the rich and the poor.
As the film continued, I realized that the directors and author of the novel that the movie was based on were pretty much wrong in the direction our society took. They completely disregarded progressive of society and industry. Currently, when we think of what America will look like in a hundred years, we think of a Jetsons futuristic vision filled with flying cars. Metropolis demonstrated that the people in the 1920’s did not have the same vision of progress in technology and social areas that we currently do in the Untied States.
Overall, the film was midely entertaining but more important highlighted the major issues that Americans faced in the early 1920’s. There was prosperity during this time period; however, many Americans were not able to partake in the consumer culture because they work in the industrial sector, like coal and textile, they were minorities or lastly they lived and work in rural communities.
Metropolis
American Neutrality
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Metropolis
Metropolis
Women were "rebelling" by becoming more provocative with their outfits and actions. This was portrayed in the "eternal gardens" of the film or the "upper world." After all, this was the era of the flappers. The film also expressed the political corruption unfolding at the time. There was a great deal of power lying in the hands of the elite, not in the hands of the working class. The film presented the battle between capital and labor.
When the film reached the United States, it had been altered, which I think allowed the movie to hit home for many Americans. After all, many Americans took offense that the film was belittling the importance of mass production, especially with the help of Henry Ford. Americans felt society was improving but little did they know it was going to collapse soon enough. It was almost too good to be true. The 1920s were definitely transitional years in American society and the World War played a role in these changes. Businessmen were making continual efforts to prevent rebellions yet it was bound to happen this relates to how Americans were trying to unionize. The film depicts a situation where the group of factory workers join together as one.
As a read through Chapter 24 about the 1920s and then related it to the film, it was interesting to see how many parallels I could find! I was not expecting to be able to write a paper that used a film as a gateway to researching a period of time. Apparently, the world was not blind to the changes happening even if it was across an ocean.
The US's role in WWI
Chapter 23
The United States entered the war on the side of the Allies, who ended the war in 1918. Unfortunately for 18 year old men and older were subjected to the Selective Service Act, which is still a huge landmark in a young man's life. Even though the military represented the government, discrimination was still evident and practiced. IQ tests were used a justification for discrimination, which does not seem appropriate at all since there was not even equal opportunities to get an education.
In today's day and age, the Prohibition Act would not have gotten by at all. Many people would be outraged by such an idea. College students would argue without the manufacturing and distribution of alcohol, college life would not be the same. Whether that is true or not is always open for discussion.
Meanwhile, the Red Scare also became a problem during the early part of the 20th century. Some would have preferred the government to be controlled by the Socialist party rather than a Republican or Democratic candidate. Ironically, the American economy was one of the strongest in the world a year after the war ended. The war allowed manufacturers to master their productivity skills, which was still put to use after the war's end. There was no need to put a stop to something so successful. Going into the 1920s, there was a push to decrease the differences between the two classes. Soldiers were returning back to the homeland so the social aspect of the country was about to change yet again. The United States seems to be a country that continuously experiences change! We just do not settle for anything less than the latest and greatest! Why not strive to succeed?